Parliamentary panel recommends removal of minor heritage sites from ASI list

September 25, 2023

A parliamentary panel has recommended the removal of ‘minor’ heritage sites that have no ‘national significance’ from the list of protected monuments of the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI).

In its report on the functioning of the ASI, the standing committee on transport, tourism and culture of Rajya Sabha suggested rationalisation and re-categorisation of the list.

The committee headed by V Vijayasai Reddy of YSR Congress also advised the ASI to develop preservation plans for all its work, especially before commencing excavations.

The report, tabled in both Houses of Parliament during the special session, mentioned 75 graves of colonial-era soldiers and officials in Karnataka to justify the recommendation for downsizing the inventory. “For example, a small brick wall enclosure containing two graves located in Kumta, Karnataka, is a centrally protected monument under the supervision of the ASI. The graves are those of public works department engineer John Albert Cope (died in 1880) and Henry Gassen (1877) who worked for a cotton ginning company. The structure had no architectural value, yet, they are supposed to get the same level of protection,” the report said.

The committee said that the list should be rationalised and categorised on the basis of their national significance, unique architectural value and specific heritage content.

It also flagged random restoration being carried out by the ASI without referring to the original design. “We recommend that the ASI must draw from its vast expertise in the field and adhere to the cardinal tenets of restoration that seeks to repair retaining the structural originality rather than replacing it,” the report read.

Share with others